Introduction to the Importance of Ethics in Cybersecurity

In today's digital world, the role of ethics in cybersecurity extends beyond simple data protection; it involves upholding core moral principles. As our reliance on technology grows, so does the importance of ethical considerations in preventing data breaches and cyberattacks that could have devastating consequences. This article delves into why ethical practices are crucial in cybersecurity, examining both the negative impacts of ethical lapses and the positive outcomes of ethical diligence. By grasping the ethical duties inherent in cybersecurity, professionals can more effectively manage the complexities of digital defence, creating a more secure environment for everyone.

What is ethics in the context of cybersecurity?

In a more general context, ethics can refer to a set of rules, guidelines or code of conduct to be followed. It guides professionals as to what they ought and ought not to do. They not only ease decision-making but also help professionals navigate the ‘grey area’, instances where the right and the wrong seem interchangeable. 

Cybersecurity ethics basically means ensuring the safety of systems, data, and networks is in line with moral principles. Ethics play an increasingly prominent role as professionals from the field face security dilemmas that require introspection every day. Both legal and social implications should be considered while determining the final course of action. All cybersecurity professionals should complete the necessary training when it comes to ethical compliance - whether it's through a Master of Cyber Security or other online programs and courses

What are some important principles of cybersecurity ethics?

While no comprehensive guide can feasibly exist covering all ethical conundrums, considering some core principles while making the final call can ensure an outcome morally satisfying for all:

1. Transparency

All important actions must be duly recorded and conveyed to the relevant stakeholders. The policy must be clearly stated. If immediate remedial action cannot be pursued, any breach of consequence must be immediately conveyed. For example, if there is a major data breach at a bank, all the stakeholders, including the customers, should be immediately informed to ensure full transparency.  

2. Confidentiality 

Image Credit: Freepik

This is a core element of the profession. Critical developments and information must be kept away from unauthorised access. Only the necessary stakeholders should be notified. This is vital to safeguard privacy and minimise risk. For example, if vulnerabilities to patient datasets are discovered by the cybersecurity team at a hospital, the information should be shared with only the relevant security team till the issue is resolved. In such instances, it is important to control the information flow to prevent the chances of an attack before the system is fixed. 

3. Accountability

Image Credit: Freepik

Being accountable for action is of utmost importance in this field.  Admin user activities should be properly logged in and logged out to keep accurate records and hold individuals accountable for legal consequences. This would ensure that the individual, and not the whole team is answerable in case of any malpractice, security measure, decision or event that may occur in a given timeframe.  To ease this process, every action performed by a system admin, like changing system configuration, accessing files of sensitive nature, or installing third-party software, can be automatically recorded with timestamps, user ID, and specific actions taken.

5. Privacy

In this context, privacy refers to respecting an individual’s right to control his or her own personal data. Cybersecurity professionals need to ensure that personal data is used appropriately. Anonymising data when sharing with people from other departments or organisations can also be a good standard operating procedure to follow. 

6. Compliance

Taking the necessary steps to ensure systems and processes follow the necessary rules, regulations, and laws is a must. Consider this a hedge against future litigation. Following the stated laws would ensure that things are being run fairly. For instance, a company collecting data from customers in the EU must follow GDPR regulations about data collection storage and customer permission. 

7. Integrity

In this instance, integrity refers to the sanctity of data. All necessary precautions must be taken to ensure data is not tampered with. It should remain in the same pristine condition without any intentional deletion or modification. Giving editable access to a smaller group of people could be a good starting point. This principle would be extremely critical for companies that dabble in healthcare and financial data. 

What are some common ethical dilemmas in cybersecurity?

As stated before, cybersecurity professionals face countless ethical conundrums on the job. In this section, some of the more common ones are discussed below:

1. Privacy and security

70% of Australians do not feel in control of their digital data. On the other hand, cybersecurity attacks are on the rise, with a 32% increase in reported attacks. Balancing privacy with security has been an age-old battle for policymakers and, later, technologists across the globe. Privacy is a modern fundamental human right enshrined in multiple constitutions of many democracies. Security is vital to maintain stability and continuity. Cybersecurity executives will have to strike a balance between effective security practices and potential infringement of individual privacy.

2. Disclosing vulnerabilities.

This is a two-fold dilemma. First, should the vulnerability be made public before getting the issue fixed? Doing so too early could attract hackers and other malicious action but delaying too much could violate the principle of transparency. Second, should the vulnerability be made public if it harms business interests? In many cases, even disclosing any major vulnerability can have a tangible negative impact on the business. A social media company admitting that its encrypted chats are not functioning properly could lead to a potential mass exodus of active users. In such instances, timing the disclosure is the key.

3. Disclosing facts.

In some extreme cases, cybersecurity professionals could face the grave conundrum of going public about questionable practices. This can be compounded by the fact that the professionals could be fired or even face legal challenges in lieu of a breach of contract. A rather popular example of this is the case of Edward Snowden, the man who unveiled the NSA’s nefarious surveillance practices. 

Future of Cybersecurity Ethics

With an increasingly higher proportion of tasks being automated by Artificial Intelligence, guardrails should be implemented to ensure that algorithmic bias for user profiling and threat detection is minimised. Additionally, as the scope of surveillance expands due to improvements in tracking technology, protecting users has to be balanced with maintaining privacy. Creating a global standard of ethical practices and policies could be the right way forward., especially as state-sponsored cyber attacks are on the rise. Governments could also look at strengthening the protection for whistleblowers through better legislation. All things considered, there are multiple variables at play. All the stakeholders need to come together to ensure an ethical and balanced future for all

(Disclaimer: Devdiscourse's journalists were not involved in the production of this article. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of Devdiscourse and Devdiscourse does not claim any responsibility for the same.)